Common Mistakes in a Background Check That Hurt Your Credit

By Matt Cook Esq


July 11, 2024

In today's world, background checks that delve into your credit history have become the norm. Whether it's employers, landlords, or lenders, they all want to gauge your financial responsibility. Accuracy in these reports is not just important—it's absolutely critical.

Unfortunately, errors on credit reports are surprisingly common. A simple typo, a case of mistaken identity, or even outdated information can have devastating consequences on your life.

That's where we come in. In this blog post, we're shining a light on the most frequent mistakes lurking in background checks that focus on your credit. We'll delve into the real-world impact these errors can have, and most importantly, we'll arm you with the knowledge and strategies to fight back and protect your hard-earned financial reputation.

Mistakes in a Background Check FI


Mistake 1: Mistaken Identity Mishap

Your name, date of birth, and Social Security number (SSN) are the building blocks of your financial identity. Even a small error in any of these can wreak havoc on your credit report and background checks. Consider these scenarios:

  • Similar Names: If you share a common name with someone else, especially someone with poor credit history, you could find yourself saddled with their financial baggage.
  • Typos and Transpositions: A simple typo, like an extra letter in your last name or a transposed number in your SSN, can link you to the wrong credit file.
  • Identity Theft: While not a "mistake" per se, if someone uses your information fraudulently, their negative credit actions could show up on your report.

The consequences of mistaken identity are serious. It can lead to:

  • Denied credit applications
  • Higher interest rates on loans
  • Difficulty renting an apartment
  • Even problems securing employment

Remember, your credit report is your financial fingerprint. Be vigilant about its accuracy, and don't hesitate to take action if you spot any mistakes.

Mistake 2: Outdated Information Haunts You

Your credit report isn't meant to be a time capsule. It should reflect your current financial situation, not a snapshot from years ago. Yet, it's surprisingly common to find outdated information clinging to your report like a ghost from your past. This could include:

  • Old Addresses: Perhaps you've moved several times since college, but your credit report still lists your childhood home.

  • Past Employment: A job you left five years ago might still be listed as your current employer.

  • Paid-Off Debts: Even after you've paid off a debt in full, it might still appear on your report, potentially lowering your credit score.

The good news is that the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) sets limits on how long most negative information can stay on your credit report. For instance, late payments generally fall off after seven years, while bankruptcies can linger for up to 10 years.

However, outdated positive information, like on-time payments or good credit accounts, can remain indefinitely. While this might seem beneficial, it can sometimes create confusion or even raise red flags for potential lenders if it doesn't match your current financial picture.

Remember, keeping your credit report accurate and up to date is crucial for your financial well-being. Don't let outdated information hold you back from achieving your financial goals.

Mistake 3: Criminal Record Resurrection

Mistakes in a Background Check: Criminal Record

For those who have worked hard to put past mistakes behind them, the idea of an expunged or sealed criminal record reappearing on a background check is a chilling prospect. While expungement or sealing is designed to give individuals a fresh start, errors can occur, and these records may sometimes resurface.

This can happen due to outdated databases, reporting errors by third-party background check companies, or even confusion with records belonging to someone with a similar name.

The consequences of having an expunged record reappear can be devastating. It can lead to:

  • Job rejections: Many employers automatically disqualify applicants with criminal records, even if they've been expunged.
  • Housing denials: Landlords may refuse to rent to individuals with a criminal history, regardless of their current circumstances.
  • Difficulty obtaining loans: Lenders may view someone with a past criminal record as a higher risk, leading to loan denials or less favorable terms.

It's important to note that laws regarding expungement and sealing vary from state to state. If you're unsure about your rights, it's crucial to consult with an experienced attorney who can guide you through the process and ensure your records are properly cleared.

Don't let errors in background checks overshadow your efforts to move forward.

Mistake 4: Eliminating Duplicates & Mislabeled Offenses

Your credit report should be an accurate reflection of your financial history, not a broken record. Unfortunately, mistakes can happen, leading to duplicate entries for the same offense or mislabeling of the severity of a past infraction. For example, a single late payment might appear multiple times, or a misdemeanor could be mistakenly listed as a felony.

These errors can have a snowball effect on your financial health. Duplicate negative marks unfairly drag down your credit score, while mislabeled offenses can cast an unwarranted shadow over your past. This can make it harder to qualify for loans, secure housing, or even land your dream job.

Take control of your credit report by:

  1. Scrutinizing Every Detail: Comb through your report line by line, looking for any duplicate entries or inaccurate classifications.

  2. Disputing Errors Promptly: If you find any discrepancies, immediately file a dispute with the credit bureau in question. Provide clear evidence of the correct information, such as court documents or police reports.

  3. Documenting Your Communication: Keep detailed records of all your interactions with the credit bureaus, including dates, names, and reference numbers. This will help you track your progress and potentially escalate the issue if needed.

Your credit report is a powerful tool that can open doors or slam them shut. Don't let duplicate entries or mislabeled offenses stand in the way of your financial goals.

At the End of the Day

Mistakes in a Background Check: Lawyer

Your credit report is more than just a collection of numbers and letters; it's a narrative of your financial life. Don't let mistakes in background checks control that narrative. Regular reviews of your credit report, prompt action to dispute errors, and the knowledge that you have the right to seek legal help are your keys to protecting your financial future.

If you've been affected by background check mistakes or are concerned about the accuracy of your credit report, our team of experienced credit lawyers is here to help. We can guide you through the dispute process, advocate for your rights, and work tirelessly to restore your financial reputation. Don't let errors hold you back – take the first step towards a brighter financial future today.

About the Author


Matthew Cook

While many lawyers may not understand The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) and The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), Matthew excels in these areas. However, what truly sets him apart is his personal touch. He prioritizes open communication and responsiveness with his clients, ensuring they fully understand the legal process by explaining complex concepts in simple terms. Matthew's unwavering goal is to achieve the quickest and most favorable results for each individual.

If you find yourself struggling with the pains of bad credit and overwhelming debt, don't hesitate to reach out to Matthew Cook.

Message An Attorney